The model minority to pick on.
Unlike many Asian Americans, I’ve never taken umbrage at being labeled as the “model minority.” In fact, I take it as a compliment. Yes, I know that outside of Hawaii, Asians in America are more appropriately separated dichotomously, as opposed to a bell-shaped curve, in terms of socioeconomics, with the average Hmong being less educated than someone whose family was rich enough to escape Hong Kong before the Red takeover, but in general we do pretty well. (I think the Southeast Asian groups as a whole will catch up eventually**.)
Though we comprise probably around 4% of the general population, across the nation we were roughly 20-30% of all the incoming 1st-year medical students when I was applying for admission. According to the U.S. Census in the year 2000, compared to Whites, Blacks and Latinos, the ethnic groups of Chinese, Japanese, Korean, Filipino and Vietnamese had higher family incomes and % of college degrees (except Vietnamese, who had a lower % than Caucasians). Go to California and you’ll see that UCLA, USC, and UCI have been renamed the University of Chinese who Left Asia, the University of Spoiled Chinese (shame, shame on one of the Ting Twins for using steroids!), and the University of Chinese Immigrants. In the medicine world, I’m starting to see more and more Jewish doctors being replaced in academia by Chinese and Asian Indians.
It’s so good/bad that Asians are being penalized for being Yellow when it comes to applying for school. (The average Asian American had to score higher on his/her MCAT than any other race to get into medical school, when I got in.)
The reason why my father moved from Taiwan with just $50 in his pocket was so I could be a model minority: someone who worked hard, did well in school and didn’t cause trouble, and not someone who spent his days collecting welfare, using his government cheese to fund his nights smoking out (something that spans all races).
And yes, I know that there is a lot of heterogeneity within Blacks, Whites, and Latinos, but that is irrelevant to what this post is eventually going to be about.
The only thing about the model minority stereotype that bothers me is that we’re so obedient and nice that we can be picked on with impunity, without any fear of retaliation.
A Golf Channel anchor got suspended for making a comment about other losing golfers wanting to “lynch” Tiger Woods, and yet John McCain once unapologetically said to the media, “I hated the gooks, I will hate them as long as I live,” without much uproar. Yes, THE John McCain who is the Republican candidate for president and has more than a puncher’s chance at winning. (John McCain suffered as a prisoner of war in Vietnam, but would it be okay if Giuliani was mugged in Harlem and in response said, “I hated the niggers,” to the Today Show?) Duane Chapman, star of “Dog: Bounty Hunter,” was vilified nationally and had his show pulled for using the “N” word, and yet I have not heard a single peep (outside of www.angryasianman.com) about the University of Colorado newspaper column that Max Karson wrote, calling for Asian students to be kidnapped and forced to play Dance Dance Revolution and that they need booster seats (among other racist remarks he made).
Now, obviously…Karson has more issues than Time Magazine. One can only guess whether it’s possible that his mom didn’t breastfeed him enough, that his body resembles that of a prepubescent female, or that all the pretty Asian girls won’t give him enough cowbell to cure his Yellow Fever, but something decaying in his cranium causes him to produce misogynistic and racist diatribes that have gotten him suspended multiple times and even arrested (for making Virginia Tech comments in class sympathetic with the shooter). With a misanthrope like Karson, the final solution would be to ignore him and then he’ll fade into obscurity and irrelevancy (probably what he fears the most in life besides women), but what ultimately bothers me is that the editors of his newspaper and one of their faculty advisors defended his column with the ubiquitous “freedom of speech” argument. The truth is that those editors and faculty advisors are racially biased and cowards. If Karson had written that African American students should be kidnapped, forced to eat watermelon and go practice dribbling a basketball, or that Hispanic American students should be kidnapped, sprayed with salsa and forced to pick strawberries, there is no way that column would have been published or that they would be defending it. They are also hypocrites, defending his column with “free speech” and then removing the comments section (which prior to removal was overwhelmingly filled with condemnations of the post).
But the question still remains, why is there such a paucity of hesitancy in regards to attacking Asian Americans? Is it, perhaps, because we have not lashed back violently as a group? We do not have the Rodney King, Watts, or Zoot Suit Riots to wear as badges and for the media to bring up everytime there is unrest among the scions of the East. Is it, perhaps, because we are viewed as the eternal immigrant, never truly American no matter how long we’ve been here or how well we speak English? We can blame the national media and the ignorance of others all we want, but part of the blame should lie with us (Asian Americans). Have we become complacent in our prosperity? Are we unwilling to be cast in the same negative light as militants like Al Sharpton and Maxine Waters? Have we forgotten that the United States of America was born out of a desire to lash out against tyranny? Whatever the reason…
We should no longer sit silently as others impugn us.
We should no longer stifle our rage when a young man like Michael Cho gets gunned down with 10 bullets, though he was not carrying a gun or knife himself.
We should no longer play deaf when a presidential candidate calls us a derogatory, racist term.
We should no longer turn the other cheek when a Washington, DC, court allows a judge to sue a Korean immigrant couple for $65 million over a single pair of lost pants, causing them to shut their business down.
I’m not saying that we should be like other groups have in the past and commit violence, looting and attacking innocent people. (I would never condone that or any other illegal activity.) But within Asian America, we have a tremendous amount of financial resources and some of the best minds in the country. Perhaps it is time that we start using them so that the rest of the country will learn that the Model Minority must be respected. If we put aside our own prejudicial views against each other (i.e. Korean vs. Japanese) and rage together, then perhaps the other 96% of this country will know how much strength 4% can truly possess. Perhaps it is no longer time to let the slumbering lion sleep.
So stand up, speak up and be heard. Otherwise your children will inherit a life devoid of respect.
Can I get an Amen?
———-
**Just to be clear, the Hmong ethnic group is orginally from China (though they are not considered “Chinese”), where many of them still reside, but in a prior era a large number migrated to SE Asia (Laos, Thailand, Vietnam) and it is from this region that many Hmong have come to the USA from.
———-
If you would like to voice your opinions to Max Karson or the Univ. of Colorado newspaper staff, you can contact them at: max.karson@colorado.edu and newstips@thecampuspress.com (these emails are publicly listed on the newspaper website).
———-
My thoughts on America’s Best Dance Crew
- Who would’ve thought that JC Chasez from NSYNC would be the one who gives the best constructive criticism? Why is Lil Mama there? She only says one of 4 things in her critiques: That’s hot, I loved it, That’s tight, or You need to pick it up. (I think Randy Jackson probably gets a cut of her album sales.)
- Can someone please put us out of our misery and kick BreakSk8 off the show?
- In the 1st two weeks I was a big Kaba Modern fan, but now I think the JabbaWockeeZ are going to murder everyone and take the 100-large home. (Next year I want to see Victor Kim and Quest enter this competition!)
Have a great week!!!
Recent Comments